What is it about?
Traditional masculinity norms, which emphasize emotional restraint, dominance, and avoidance of so-called feminine traits, continue to shape how many men see themselves and relate to others. But where might the pressure to change these norms come from? This research examines one underexplored source: the everyday practices of sexual minority men. Across two studies in the U.S. and U.K., we compared heterosexual and gay men's attitudes toward masculinity, then experimentally tested whether reading about gay men embracing non-traditional roles, such as caregiving and flexible relationship practices, could shift heterosexual men's views. Gay men reported greater openness to these roles and greater willingness to be emotionally vulnerable. Among heterosexual men, exposure to a short narrative framing these practices positively led to lower endorsement of traditional masculinity and greater emotional openness. The key mechanism was role embracement: the domestic and relational practices that many sexual minority men adopt in daily life help explain why they hold more flexible gender attitudes.
Featured Image
Photo by Markus Winkler on Unsplash
Why is it important?
Rigid masculinity norms carry real costs, contributing to emotional suppression, poorer mental health, and strained relationships among men. Most interventions target individual attitudes directly, but this research points to a different lever: the normative influence of minority groups. A brief, realistic narrative about how some men already live differently was enough to move majority-group attitudes, suggesting practical pathways for media campaigns, workplace diversity initiatives, and public health messaging. The findings also advance minority influence theory by showing that group-level norms from marginalized communities can function as a meaningful source of social change, not just individual role models. At a moment when public discourse around masculinity is intensifying globally, this work offers evidence that change is possible and points to one mechanism through which it can occur.
Perspectives
This paper sits at the intersection of two questions I keep returning to in my research: how do social norms shape intergroup relations, and what actually moves people toward more inclusive ways of living together? What I find most compelling about this work is the idea that normative change does not have to come from above, through policy or formal education, but can emerge from the visible, everyday practices of groups who have found their own path around restrictive social scripts. I also hope it contributes to broadening how we think about minority influence, moving it beyond laboratory attitude change toward questions that matter for gender equality and men's wellbeing in the real world.
Dr Islam Borinca
Read the Original
This page is a summary of: Challenging traditional masculinity: minority norms and the reimagining of male gender roles, Social Influence, July 2025, Taylor & Francis,
DOI: 10.1080/15534510.2025.2538627.
You can read the full text:
Contributors
The following have contributed to this page
