What is it about?
The paper is focused on the approximation of absorbed Charpy impact energy-temperature curves and the management of sub-size test piece results in Charpy pendulum impact tests. Both subjects are frequently underestimated but may have a strong impact on the assessment of product quality and structural integrity. proportional scaling of sub-size to full-size test piece results in terms of KV should be disallowed because it is a wrong approach. Regulations still incorporating such procedures should be revised as soon as possible. Existing nonproportional scaling and conversion procedures were applied. The results obtained illustrate that neither an overall nor consistent conservativeness nor an adequate conservativeness level can be achieved. In summary, the standardizing bodies should enforce the discussion to revise relevant test standards considering more precise specifications on Charpy data fitting. Furthermore, proposals are made for an improved management of sub-size test piece results.
Featured Image
Why is it important?
The subjects of the paper, the approximation of absorbed Charpy impact energy-temperature curves and the management of sub-size test piece results from Charpy pendulum impact tests, are frequently underestimated. But they may have a strong impact on the assessment of product quality and structural integrity, since current product standards and integrity assessment procedures provide incorrect and/or insufficient information.
Perspectives
The standardizing bodies should enforce the discussion to revise relevant test standards considering more precise specifications on Charpy data fitting. And the bodies responsible for steel product standards as well as structural integrity assessment procedures should disallow proportional scaling of sub-size to full-size test piece results in terms of KV in pleinty of standards because it is a wrong approach.
Wolfram Baer
Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing (BAM), Germany
Read the Original
This page is a summary of: On the Question of How to Analyze and Apply Charpy Pendulum Impact Test Results Correctly - Shortcomings in Corresponding Procedures and Standards, Journal of Testing and Evaluation, May 2022, ASTM International,
DOI: 10.1520/jte20210781.
You can read the full text:
Contributors
The following have contributed to this page







