What is it about?

European governments pay farmers to adopt environmentally friendly farming practices. But do these financial incentives actually change how farmers manage their land? Our study examines whether participation in the European Union's agri-environmental schemes helps farmers reduce their use of fertilisers, which are essential for growing crops but can also contribute to water pollution and other environmental problems. Using data from 957 Hungarian farms between 2014 and 2020, we investigated how fertiliser use changed when farmers joined or left these schemes. We also examined whether participation affected agricultural productivity. We found little evidence that joining an environmental scheme led to lasting reductions in fertiliser use. Although potassium fertiliser use decreased shortly after farmers joined, this reduction was not sustained. We also found no statistically significant changes in overall fertiliser use or land productivity. These findings do not necessarily mean that environmental schemes are ineffective. They may provide other benefits, such as protecting biodiversity, improving soil health or preserving landscapes, which our data could not directly measure. Our research highlights an important lesson for policymakers: **paying farmers to participate in environmental programmes does not automatically guarantee changes in farming practices.** To make public spending more effective, governments need to set clear environmental objectives, monitor actual outcomes and provide support that helps farmers adopt sustainable practices. The findings are relevant to policymakers, researchers and agricultural organisations seeking to improve the environmental effectiveness of the European Union's Common Agricultural Policy.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

Our research provides new evidence on whether financial incentives for environmentally friendly farming actually lead to changes in agricultural practices. While many studies focus on farmers' participation in environmental programmes, we examine what happens to fertiliser use when farmers join or leave these schemes. What makes our study distinctive is its use of seven years of farm-level data from 957 Hungarian farms and advanced statistical methods that help distinguish the effects of policy participation from differences between farms. By examining nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium separately, we also provide a more detailed understanding of farmers' responses to environmental incentives. The research is particularly timely as the European Union seeks to make its Common Agricultural Policy more environmentally effective while maintaining agricultural productivity and food security. Our findings challenge the assumption that financial incentives automatically lead to more sustainable farming practices. The study offers an important message for policymakers: **environmental policy success should be measured by actual changes and outcomes, not simply by the number of farmers receiving payments.** Our findings can help inform the design and evaluation of future agricultural support programmes by encouraging better targeting, clearer environmental objectives, improved monitoring and more effective advisory support. They also highlight the need for better data to assess environmental benefits that cannot be captured by fertiliser use alone. Ultimately, our research contributes to the wider debate on how public funding can deliver measurable environmental benefits while supporting economically viable farming.

Perspectives

What I find particularly important about this research is that it challenges a common assumption in agricultural policy: providing financial incentives for environmentally friendly farming does not necessarily lead to measurable changes in farmers' behaviour. As an agricultural economist, I am especially interested in understanding whether public policies achieve their intended objectives, rather than simply measuring how much money is spent or how many farmers participate. Our findings highlight the importance of distinguishing between policy participation and genuine environmental additionality. I also believe that results showing limited or statistically insignificant effects are valuable. They help us identify where existing policies may need improvement and encourage more realistic expectations about what financial incentives can achieve. For me, the broader message of this study is that sustainable agriculture requires more than financial support. Effective policies need clearly defined objectives, appropriate incentives, reliable evidence and an understanding of the economic realities farmers face. I hope our research will encourage policymakers and researchers to focus more closely on what actually changes because of public intervention. Ultimately, better evaluation can contribute to better agricultural policies that protect the environment while maintaining economically viable farming.

Professor Imre Fertő
Eotvos Lorand Tudomanyegyetem

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Incentivising sustainable fertiliser management: dynamic causal evidence from Hungarian farms, Environmental Sciences Europe, October 2026, Springer Science + Business Media,
DOI: 10.1186/s12302-026-01542-1.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page