What is it about?

This study looks into how a statistical method called the design-comparable effect size (D-CES) influences the analysis of single-case designs (SCDs) in special education research. SCDs are a type of research method that focuses on studying individuals repeatedly over time, rather than comparing groups of people. Single-case designs are widely used in special education. Traditional analysis of SCDs relies on visually examining graphs, which shows how an intervention affects an individual's behavior over time. Recently, there has been a push to use more standardized statistical methods, like D-CES, to analyze these studies. This is because standardized methods can make it easier to compare findings across different studies and integrate SCD results with those from group studies. The What Works Clearinghouse (WWC), a body that evaluates educational research, has adopted D-CES for this purpose. This study reviewed 1,425 SCD articles published in special education journals from 1999 to 2021 to see if they met the criteria for D-CES analysis.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

This article contributes to a larger discussion regarding evidence-based practices. Single-case designs are a cornerstone of special eduction research and are increasingly common in other fields. The D-CES is a relatively novel means of analysis and is a key aspect of guidelines disseminated by Department of Education. Two significant findings are that (1) Nearly 60% of the reviewed SCD studies did not meet criteria for D-CES analysis and (2) journals focusing on developmental disabilities had the highest rate of studies that did not meet D-CES criteria. This article underscores the importance of using inclusive evaluation methods when attempting to identify evidence-based practices.

Perspectives

The growing popularity of SCD has been exciting to watch and has spurred intense debate regarding the propriety of both time-honored conventions and innovative techniques. I consider this article a meaningful contribution to the ongoing conversation about D-CES and other analyses in SCD research.

Seth King
University of Iowa

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Examining the impact of design-comparable effect size on the analysis of single-case design in special education., School Psychology, May 2024, American Psychological Association (APA),
DOI: 10.1037/spq0000628.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page