What is it about?
Religious and spiritual beliefs can be an important source of meaning and support, but they can also become a source of conflict or distress. In this study, we compared religious and spiritual struggles among LGBTQ+ and cisheterosexual adults in Puerto Rico and examined how these struggles were related to anxiety, depression, and life satisfaction. LGBTQ+ participants reported more religious and spiritual struggles overall, particularly struggles involving relationships with the divine, interactions with religious communities, moral concerns, doubts, and questions about the meaning or purpose of life. These struggles were also more strongly related to poorer mental health and lower life satisfaction among LGBTQ+ participants. Questions about the meaning and purpose of life were especially important, showing the strongest relationship with anxiety, depression, and lower life satisfaction. The findings highlight the importance of understanding how religion and spirituality can be experienced not only as sources of support, but also as sources of distress for some LGBTQ+ individuals.
Featured Image
Photo by Gioele Fazzeri on Unsplash
Why is it important?
Religion and spirituality are deeply embedded in many people’s lives and are often treated as sources of comfort, meaning, and resilience. However, this perspective can overlook the fact that religious and spiritual experiences may also become sources of conflict, especially for LGBTQ+ individuals who encounter rejection, condemnation, or tension between their identities and religious beliefs. Understanding this distinction is particularly important in Puerto Rico, where religion remains culturally influential but research on religious and spiritual struggles among LGBTQ+ populations is still limited. This study is important because it moves beyond asking whether religion is simply “helpful” or “harmful.” Instead, it shows that specific types of religious and spiritual conflict matter, and that struggles involving meaning and purpose are especially relevant to anxiety, depression, and life satisfaction. This helps clarify which aspects of religious and spiritual experience may be most closely connected to psychological distress. The findings also have practical relevance for mental health care. Clinicians working with LGBTQ+ clients may need to assess religious and spiritual experiences as part of case conceptualization, particularly when clients are navigating identity conflict, rejection from religious communities, or questions about meaning and purpose. More broadly, the study supports a more culturally sensitive and LGBTQ+-affirming understanding of religion and spirituality—one that recognizes that they can function as sources of support, distress, or both.
Perspectives
As an LGBTQ+ researcher, this topic is personally important to me. I believe we need to deconstruct the assumption that religion and spirituality, particularly religion, are inherently synonymous with wellness, morality, or goodness. For many people, they can be meaningful sources of support and community. For others, especially LGBTQ+ individuals, they can also become sources of rejection, shame, conflict, and psychological distress. Recognizing this complexity does not require rejecting religion or spirituality. It requires acknowledging that their effects depend greatly on the beliefs, messages, and environments in which they are experienced. I hope this work contributes to a more nuanced conversation in which religious and spiritual experiences are not automatically assumed to be beneficial, and in which the experiences of LGBTQ+ people who have been harmed within religious contexts are taken seriously.
Dr. Caleb Esteban
Ponce Health Sciences University
Read the Original
This page is a summary of: Religious and spiritual struggles, anxiety, depression, and life satisfaction among lesbian, gay, bisexual, trans, and queer (LGBTQ+) individuals in Puerto Rico., Psychology of Religion and Spirituality, November 2026, American Psychological Association (APA),
DOI: 10.1037/rel0000654.
You can read the full text:
Contributors
The following have contributed to this page







