Women-Managed Wineries Are More Likely to Hold Organic Certification

What is it about?

This study looks at whether wineries managed by women and men differ in their likelihood of having organic certification. Using survey data from Hungarian wineries, we find that female-managed wineries are more often organically certified, even though they report broadly similar environmental practices, management capabilities, education, and firm characteristics. The factors measured in the survey explain very little of this difference. This does not mean that gender itself causes certification, nor does it prove discrimination or unequal treatment. The remaining gap may reflect factors that were not captured in the survey, such as market strategy, access to advice, customer relationships, certification costs, administrative experience, or the history of the winery. The main message is that using environmentally friendly practices and obtaining formal organic certification are not the same thing. Better data are needed to understand why similar wineries make different certification choices and how producers can be supported in turning sustainable practices into formally recognized standards.

Featured Image

Photo by Zach Lisko on Unsplash

Photo by Zach Lisko on Unsplash

Why is it important?

What makes this study distinctive is that it separates the use of environmentally friendly practices from the decision to obtain formal organic certification. Most research treats these outcomes as closely connected, but our findings show that wineries reporting similar sustainability practices can still differ markedly in certification status. Female-managed Hungarian wineries are more likely to be certified than male-managed wineries, and the observed differences in practices, capabilities, education, land, and firm characteristics explain little of this gap. The study is timely because organic certification is increasingly used by consumers, businesses, and policymakers as a visible signal of sustainability. Our results show why certification should not automatically be treated as a complete measure of environmental commitment. The findings may help researchers design better studies and encourage certifiers, advisers, and policymakers to examine how market access, administrative support, information, and certification procedures influence who becomes certified. Ultimately, this could lead to more accessible certification systems and more accurate evaluation of sustainability in the wine sector and other high-value food industries.

Perspectives