What is it about?

We often think of places as fixed locations and mobility as movement between them. This article shows that the relationship is much more complex. Places are continually made and remade through the movements of people, objects, ideas and information, while every form of mobility is itself shaped by the places through which it occurs. This means that places can, in important ways, be mobile, while mobility is always connected to particular environments, relationships and experiences. The article brings these two perspectives together and explores what they mean for how we understand belonging, home, displacement and being unable to move. It argues that looking at place and mobility together gives us a richer understanding of how people experience and navigate an increasingly interconnected world.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

In a world shaped by migration, travel, digital connections, globalization and other forms of movement, it is tempting to assume that place has become less important. This article argues the opposite: mobility does not make place disappear. Instead, mobility continuously creates, transforms and connects places. At the same time, where we are profoundly influences how, why and whether we can move. What is distinctive about the article is that it brings these two sides of the relationship together. Large-scale approaches to globalization often emphasize flows and connections but risk overlooking people's lived experiences of place. More locally focused approaches capture those experiences but may miss the wider structures and power relations that shape them. The article argues that we need both perspectives simultaneously. This is particularly important because mobility is not equally available to everyone. Being prevented from moving can be as significant as being forced to move, and people can even experience displacement while remaining physically in the same location. Understanding this relationship between movement, immobility and place can therefore contribute to more nuanced approaches to migration, displacement, belonging and inequality, while providing a stronger basis for research across disciplinary boundaries.

Perspectives

For me, one of the starting points of this article is a deceptively simple observation: people move, but places do too. We tend to imagine places as stable points on a map, with people travelling between them. Yet the more closely we look at people's lived experiences, the harder it becomes to maintain that distinction. Places are continually changing through the people, objects, ideas, memories and connections that move through them. And movement, in turn, always happens somewhere and acquires meaning through its relationship with particular places. As an anthropologist of mobility, I find this interplay particularly fascinating because it also forces us to look beyond movement itself. Mobility is often celebrated as freedom, opportunity and connection, but the ability to move is highly uneven. Some people travel by choice, others move because circumstances leave them little alternative, while still others would like to move but cannot. Importantly, people can also become displaced without physically going anywhere, because the social, political or cultural world around them has changed. What I hope this article encourages, therefore, is a more relational way of thinking about both mobility and place. Rather than treating roots and routes, staying and moving, or place and mobility as opposites, we can ask how they continually produce one another. This also requires being more attentive to perspectives that conventional Western theories have sometimes overlooked, including Indigenous understandings in which the distinction between moving people and supposedly fixed places may make little sense. Ultimately, understanding mobility requires understanding place, and understanding place requires understanding mobility. Holding the two together can, I believe, tell us much more about how people experience belonging, displacement and their changing position in the world.

Professor Noel B. Salazar
Katholieke Universiteit Leuven

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Mobile places and emplaced mobilities: problematizing the place-mobility nexus, Mobilities, June 2023, Taylor & Francis,
DOI: 10.1080/17450101.2023.2226358.
You can read the full text:

Read

Resources

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page