What is it about?

This study investigates how effective different common disinfectants are at killing various types of germs on hospital surfaces. The researcher tested three substances: ethanol (alcohol), isopropyl alcohol (rubbing alcohol), and a strong chemical blend of peracetic acid and hydrogen peroxide (PA+HP). They tested these against four specific microbes: Bacillus subtilis (bacterial spores, which are very tough). Aspergillus niger (fungal spores, also resistant). Candida albicans (yeast). Kocuria rosea (bacteria found on skin). Key findings include: PA+HP is the heavy hitter: It was the only thing that effectively killed the tough bacterial spores (B. subtilis), achieving a massive reduction in bacteria counts. Fungi fight back: The fungal spores (A. niger) were the hardest to kill overall, showing significant resistance even to strong chemicals. Alcohol winner: When fighting yeast (C. albicans), Ethanol proved statistically better than Isopropyl Alcohol. Surface doesn't matter much: Surprisingly, the type of surface (glass, steel, plastic, etc.) didn't change the results much; the type of germ mattered far more.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

One size does not fit all: Hospitals often rely on alcohol-based cleaners for everything, but on the other hand - alcohol proves to be useless against bacterial spores like B. subtilis (zero reduction). Patient Safety: With more immunocompromised patients in hospitals, using the wrong disinfectant can lead to dangerous infections spreading. Targeted Cleaning: The study supports "antimicrobial rotation"—switching up cleaning agents based on the specific germs present, rather than using the same cleaner for everything.

Perspectives

This research acts as a reality check for infection control. It highlights that knowing your enemy is as important as having the weapon. A hospital fighting a fungal outbreak needs completely different protocols (stronger chemicals, longer contact times) than one fighting common yeast or bacteria. It pushes for a more scientific, evidence-based approach to daily cleaning where staff choose the specific tool for the specific biological threat.

Independent Researcher & Consultant Mostafa Essam Eissa

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Evaluating the Differential Efficacy of Disinfectants Against Microbial Forms Using Logarithmic Reduction Analysis, January 2025, National Society for Biomedical Research Development,
DOI: 10.63475/yjm.v4i2.0101.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page