What is it about?

This study introduces a novel two-step panel clustering methodology to classify European countries based on the efficiency and dynamic reform trajectories of their first-instance courts: Data & Scope: Analyzes biannual panel data from the Council of Europe’s European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice (CEPEJ) covering 32 European countries from 2010 to 2020, tracking clearance rates (ratio of resolved to incoming cases) and disposition times (estimated days to resolve pending cases) separately for criminal and non-criminal cases. Two-Step CluMP Methodology vs. KML: Applies the Clustering Micro-Panel trajectories (CluMP) algorithm—first extracting seven non-parametric dynamic trajectory features (growth rates, variability, angle of change) and then grouping countries via Ward’s hierarchical clustering—and benchmarks it against the standard longitudinal KML algorithm. Superior Clustering Precision: CluMP outperforms KML on the Silhouette index in three out of four efficiency dimensions (achieving 0.55–0.75 vs. 0.36–0.74), producing more homogeneous country clusters with lower within-group variability. Criminal Justice Performance Leaders: Estonia and Georgia achieve the strongest overall results in criminal case efficiency, while Denmark, the Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Switzerland, and Slovakia maintain high, stable performance. Non-Criminal Justice Improvers vs. Laggards: Sweden and Slovakia stand out as fast-improving countries across both non-criminal clearance rates and disposition times, whereas Cyprus and Montenegro exhibit weak and deteriorating efficiency trajectories.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

Judicial efficiency directly affects business growth, financial market development, and public trust, yet most cross-country court comparisons rely on static snapshots or single-jurisdiction Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA) models that miss dynamic reform trends: Captures Dynamic Reform Trajectories: Demonstrates how longitudinal panel clustering separates countries with stable high efficiency from fast-improving reformers (such as Sweden and Slovakia) and deteriorating systems—vital for evaluating judicial digitalization and e-court reforms. Advances Quantitative Public Policy Tools: Provides researchers and policymakers with a validated, generalizable two-step clustering framework (CluMP) for benchmarking public-sector institutional performance over time. Enables Targeted Justice Policy Interventions: Helps European justice ministries identify peer benchmarks and target administrative or digital modernization efforts toward courts experiencing growing case backlogs.

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Using a Two-step Clustering Approach to Examine Judiciary Efficiency in European Countries, January 2026, Elsevier,
DOI: 10.2139/ssrn.7112018.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page