What is it about?
Understanding what keeps players engaged is central to good game design, yet it is often hard to separate the impact of game mechanics from flashy visuals and audio. In this study, we isolated pure reflex challenge in Geometry Dash by muting the sound, removing colour, and restricting controls to a single tap across easy, medium, and difficult speed tiers. Our results revealed that perceived challenge consistently drives player engagement across all speeds. However, at medium difficulty, where challenge and ability hit a sweet spot, players stopped consciously monitoring how well they were doing, entering an automatic, effortless state of reaction. Even when we pushed the speed to its highest tier, engagement did not collapse. Instead, high Flow coexisted alongside rising tension, proving that developers can dial up mechanical difficulty to create thrilling, high-arousal experiences as long as the timing remains fair and predictable.
Featured Image
Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash
Why is it important?
Video games are often studied as complex multi-sensory worlds, leaving an open question about how much player engagement comes from pure physical timing versus flashy visuals and soundtracks. Our work addresses this gap by isolating reflex-based challenge in Geometry Dash through muted audio, neutral grey visuals, and a single-tap control scheme. Showing that pure motor challenge can sustain a "Flow plateau" even under rising tension changes how we think about difficulty design. Whether building skill-focused games, adaptive difficulty systems, or accessible cognitive training exercises, designers can use calibrated speed and timing alone to keep people deeply absorbed.
Perspectives
One of my favourite moments in analysing this data was discovering how perceived competence behaved at medium difficulty. In both the easy and difficult levels, players' sense of their own skill closely tracked their Flow state, yet at medium difficulty, that link disappeared. To me, this captures the exact feeling of being "in the zone", when challenge and ability align, you stop overthinking how well you are doing and simply react. I hope this paper encourages other researchers and designers to look closely at minimalist mechanics. Sometimes stripping a system back to a single input reveals the clearest picture of how human attention and emotion work under pressure.
Zainab Ezzeddine
Edinburgh Napier University
Read the Original
This page is a summary of: Investigating the Relationship Between the Scale of Reflex-Based Challenge and Flow, Immersion, and Game Experience, January 2026, BCS Learning and Development Limited,
DOI: 10.14236/ewic/britchi26.33.
You can read the full text:
Contributors
The following have contributed to this page







