What is it about?

The relationship between how other people perceive our behavior and motivation and how we want to be perceived is part and parcel of being human. Being intimidating or ingratiating constitutes a vast spectrum of impression management strategies we use in daily life to gain influence and recognition. Researchers have found that these strategies differ by gender and cultural norms. However, there is limited research on impression management strategies in the Indian context. As a highly unequal country with a high social acceptance of these inequalities, India is also witnessing the growth of an emerging women’s movement and the presence of women in high-profile roles. Using existing research on impression management strategies, Dr Apurva Sanaria, Assistant Professor at MICA-The School of Ideas with a PhD from the XLRI-Xavier School of Management, has developed a framework to explain the impression management strategies of Indian women in the workplace. He suggests that jobs perceived as feminine or masculine and individual attitudes to gender stereotypes primarily shape Indian working women’s selection of impression management strategies, such as direct and aggressive strategies (assertiveness, self-promotion, etc.) or indirect and subtle ones (coalition, supplication, etc.).

Featured Image

Why is it important?

Gender inequality is a global scourge but it is particularly acute in India. The country has high levels of social inequalities, and its entrenched acceptance among the populace is damaging to the formation of an egalitarian and healthy society. Exploring the systemic manner in which these unequal power structures and relationships are upheld will generate solutions to mitigate and correct them. Dr Sanaria’s research into the factors that shape how Indian women manage impression formation at work will bolster employers’ and policy-makers’ efforts to produce solutions that reduce gender inequality in their organizations, and create an inclusive workplace and society.

Perspectives

A new perspective on how women manage impressions at work in India. 9 September 2021, Bangalore – A recent research paper theorizes that the perception of jobs as masculine or feminine alongside individual attitudes towards gender stereotypes shape the ways in which Indian women practice impression management in the workplace. Proposed by Dr Apurva Sanaria, Assistant Professor at Indian Institute of Management Bangalore (IIMB), the study reveals how ingrained gender stereotypes entrench gender inequality in the workplace. It then provides a framework to explain factors, such as the nature of the job and attitudes toward gender stereotypes, influence the impression management strategies that Indian women practice in the workplace. Dr. Sanaria’s paper is the first of its kind that provides insight into the unique Indian context for impression management strategies, which are tactics used to manage the impressions people form about behavior, motivation, intelligence, and future potential, among other qualities. They range from hard strategies—which are direct and aggressive, such as self-promotion and intimidation—to soft techniques which are indirect and subtle, such as ingratiation and supplication. Strategies that are stereotypically gendered as hard ones are seen as “masculine” while soft ones are labelled “feminine”. The paper proposes that whether a job is seen as stereotypically masculine (such as leadership positions) or feminine (such as teaching and nursing) and an individual’s own attitude towards gender stereotypes - whether they are likely to challenge or accept them - heavily influence the type of impression management strategies used by Indian working women. “My framework also shows that unlike western cultures, Indian women are much more likely to use impression management strategies as compared to men”, Dr Sanaria said. “This is primarily because India is a highly unequal country with a high social acceptance of these inequalities. But the country is simultaneously witnessing the growth of an emerging women’s movement and their achievements as successful entrepreneurs, employees, and business owners” . The research contributes to the knowledge of how gender stereotypes manifest themselves in the workplace, and give employers and policy-makers a further impetus to shape an equal and inclusive work environment.

Dr Apurva Dahyabhai Sanaria
Indian Institute of Management Bangalore

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: A Conceptual Framework for Understanding the Impression Management Strategies Used by Women in Indian Organizations, South Asian Journal of Human Resources Management, March 2016, SAGE Publications,
DOI: 10.1177/2322093716631118.
You can read the full text:

Read

Resources

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page