What is it about?
Small businesses often rely on knowledge and ideas from other companies to improve their products and processes. But does it matter whether these connections are within their local business community or beyond it? We studied 92 companies in the textile industry in Valencia, Spain, to examine how their ability to acquire and use knowledge interacts with their business relationships to influence incremental innovation, meaning small, continuous improvements to existing products, services and processes. Our findings show that strong connections within local industrial clusters can enhance these improvements, while connections with organisations outside the cluster have a different effect. We also found that investing more in a company's ability to use knowledge does not always lead to better innovation results. The benefits depend on the types of business relationships the company maintains.
Featured Image
Photo by Alan Aprilio on Unsplash
Why is it important?
Small businesses are often encouraged to invest in research and development and expand their networks to become more innovative. However, our research shows that more resources and more connections do not necessarily produce better results. For companies seeking to continuously improve their existing products and processes, close relationships with other businesses in their industrial cluster can be particularly valuable. By contrast, extensive connections outside the cluster may reduce the benefits of these efforts for incremental innovation, especially when firms already have strong internal knowledge capabilities. This does not mean that external connections are undesirable. They may provide valuable opportunities for more radical forms of innovation. Our findings suggest that managers and policymakers should consider not only how to strengthen business networks, but also how to align different types of relationships with companies' specific innovation objectives.
Perspectives
One of the motivations behind this research was to challenge the widespread assumption that having access to more knowledge and more business partners always improves innovation performance. What I find particularly interesting is that the value of business relationships depends on the type of innovation a company is pursuing. Knowledge obtained from nearby firms may be especially useful for continuous improvements, while more distant connections can introduce different ideas and opportunities. I believe this distinction is particularly relevant for small businesses operating in traditional industries, where innovation often involves improving existing products and processes rather than developing entirely new technologies. The key message is that successful innovation is not simply about having more connections, but about developing the right relationships for the company's strategic objectives.
José-Vicente Tomás-Miquel
Universitat Politecnica de Valencia
Read the Original
This page is a summary of: Loving Outside the Neighborhood: The Conflicting Effects of External Linkages on Incremental Innovation in Clusters, April 2018, Wiley,
DOI: 10.1111/jsbm.12439.
You can read the full text:
Contributors
The following have contributed to this page
