What is it about?

This is a case study, with important lessons learned, about dealing with -- and planning for -- acute and unprecedented turmoil in Latin America's largest automotive market.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

There's a common misconception that quantitative and qualitative approaches are at odds -- or serve different masters. Sometime you need both. This article demonstrates why and how. It also makes the case for looking out beyond the near-term to understand, in a scenario sense, how market conditions could plausibly change. The client company in this case was too focused on 0-5 years out, which was important for financial planning purposes, but blind to the pressures building beyond that relatively short-term time horizon. This was a classic case of management failing to heed qualitative insights -- which would have served them well going forward into a different, and actually quite positive, market environment.

Perspectives

My co-author Robert Avila and I have worked extensively together in challenging business environments in Latin America, where conditions can change abruptly, market data is often lacking or suspect, and the unwritten rules of engagement are challenging to discern for multinational companies. The Futures Strategy Group's tools for what we call "managing uncertainty" work well in such an environment; in fact, some were developed in the Latin American region. What we have found essential in seeking to learn underlying market dynamics is a strong sense of humility, especially about "unknown unknowns" which are invisible to researchers and analysts not resident in a country. For this reason we typically work with individuals and organizations in country, who can read and interpret political and economic signals, and who support our knowledge development efforts by conducting confidential interviews with key stakeholders and by actively contributing to scenario development. Most importantly, as consultants, we work closely with client project team, as partners, in these challenging kinds of engagements. This helps ensure that the there is a functioning action plan when the strategy work is done and that the client team feels sufficiently skilled and empowered to carry on follow-on market monitoring and contingency planning when the consultants are no longer on the scene. It's a happy formula that has served FSG and our clients well over the years.

Mr Peter J Kennedy
Futures Strategy Group

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Decision making under extreme uncertainty: blending quantitative modeling and scenario planning, Strategy & Leadership, June 2013, Emerald,
DOI: 10.1108/sl-04-2013-0025.
You can read the full text:

Read

Resources

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page