What is it about?

Have you ever been forced to make a choice when you felt you had no real choice at all? Imagine booking a flight online. You find the perfect ticket, enter your details, and are ready to pay. Suddenly, a cookie consent message appears asking you to "Accept All." You may not want to share your personal information, but rejecting the request seems difficult or impossible. You feel the process is unfair, yet you accept because you need to complete your booking. Why do we continue using digital services even when we believe their privacy practices are unfair? Our research investigates this question through what we call the Restrictiveness-Fairness Paradox. Using a mixed-methods approach involving qualitative research and two online experiments with European and non-European participants, we examined how restrictive cookie consent practices influence people's perceptions of privacy risk, control, fairness, and willingness to use digital services. We found that restrictive consent practices reduce perceived fairness, but do not necessarily discourage people from continuing to use a website. We also discovered that the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) influences how people evaluate privacy protections. European users tend to rely more on institutional safeguards, while users outside GDPR environments place greater emphasis on website-level privacy assurances. Our findings reveal an important distinction: continuing to use a digital service does not necessarily mean accepting or approving its privacy practices.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

Every day, millions of people encounter cookie banners and privacy consent requests. Although privacy regulations such as GDPR aim to strengthen transparency and user control, the existence of legal protections does not automatically guarantee that people experience meaningful choice or fairness. Our research reveals a critical problem: people may continue using digital services even when they perceive the consent process as unfair. This means that website engagement and consent acceptance should not automatically be interpreted as signs of user satisfaction, trust, or genuine agreement. The study makes an important contribution by distinguishing the Restrictiveness-Fairness Paradox from the traditional Privacy Paradox. While the Privacy Paradox focuses on why people share personal information despite privacy concerns, our research examines why people continue engaging with digital services despite judging their consent procedures as unfair. We also show that regulatory environments matter. GDPR can reduce the impact of restrictive consent on perceived privacy risk, but it does not necessarily restore users' sense of control or eliminate perceptions of unfairness. These findings have practical implications for policymakers, regulators, website designers, and businesses. Organizations should move beyond simply meeting legal requirements and consider whether their consent interfaces genuinely respect users' autonomy and expectations of fairness. To address this challenge, we introduce Fairness Calibration, an approach that encourages organizations to design privacy consent experiences that reflect users' expectations and the institutional context in which they operate. Ultimately, better privacy protection requires more than legal compliance. It requires transparency, meaningful choice, and fair treatment of users.

Perspectives

What particularly interests me about this research is the difference between what people believe is fair and what they actually choose to do. We often assume that when users accept privacy conditions and continue using a website, they are comfortable with those conditions. But our findings challenge this assumption. People may recognize that a consent process is unfair and still proceed because completing their task matters more at that moment. The flight-booking example captures this tension perfectly. When someone needs to book a flight, accepting restrictive cookies may be a practical necessity rather than a genuine expression of consent. For me, one of the most important messages of this study is that acceptance should not be confused with fairness, and compliance should not be confused with meaningful choice. I also find the differences between GDPR and non-GDPR contexts particularly interesting. They demonstrate that people's perceptions of privacy are shaped not only by website design but also by the institutional protections they believe they can rely on. I hope this research encourages organizations, policymakers, and researchers to reconsider how digital consent is designed and evaluated. Rather than asking only whether users accept privacy conditions, we should also ask whether they feel respected, informed, and genuinely free to choose.

Prof. Afshin Ashofteh
Universidade Nova de Lisboa

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Revealing the restrictiveness-fairness paradox in general data protection regulation consent practices: evidence from a mixed-methods study, Internet Research, October 2026, Emerald,
DOI: 10.1108/intr-12-2025-2077.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page