What is it about?
This study explores how CEO overconfidence influences the relationship between a company’s greenhouse gas emissions and its financial performance. Drawing on data from 1,816 US-listed companies between 2002 and 2020, we examine whether businesses with overconfident CEOs experience different financial outcomes from their carbon emissions. Our findings show that higher emissions are associated with stronger financial performance in companies led by overconfident CEOs. This relationship holds across different types of emissions and measures of profitability and market value. However, this does not mean that increasing emissions causes higher profits. The research highlights how the personality and decision-making tendencies of business leaders can influence the relationship between environmental sustainability and financial performance. It offers useful insights for investors, business leaders and policymakers seeking to balance profitability with the transition to a low-carbon economy.
Featured Image
Photo by kelisa Bernard on Unsplash
Why is it important?
As businesses face increasing pressure to reduce carbon emissions, understanding how environmental performance relates to profitability has become more important than ever. Much of the debate focuses on whether reducing emissions helps or harms financial performance, often overlooking corporate leadership. Our research shows that CEO overconfidence plays an important role in this relationship. Companies led by overconfident CEOs can exhibit stronger financial performance despite higher emissions. This challenges the assumption that higher emissions always lead to poorer financial outcomes and highlights the complexity of balancing business growth with environmental responsibility. The findings matter for investors assessing corporate environmental risks, boards overseeing executive decisions and policymakers designing effective climate policies. They also highlight why financial success should not automatically be interpreted as evidence of environmental sustainability.
Perspectives
Our research emerged from a question that is often overlooked in discussions about corporate sustainability. Why do some companies continue to achieve strong financial performance despite producing substantial greenhouse gas emissions, and what role do their leaders play in this relationship? We were particularly interested in CEO overconfidence because business decisions are not always driven by purely rational financial or environmental considerations. Executives' beliefs, judgements and willingness to take risks can influence corporate strategies and outcomes. What makes our findings interesting is that the relationship between carbon emissions and financial performance appears to differ depending on CEO overconfidence. However, financial success alongside higher emissions should not be mistaken for evidence that emissions are beneficial. We hope this research encourages greater attention to the behavioural dimensions of corporate sustainability. Achieving meaningful decarbonisation requires more than technological investment and regulatory compliance. It also requires understanding how business leaders make decisions and how corporate governance can align financial success with long-term environmental responsibility.
Dr Krish Saha
Birmingham City University
Read the Original
This page is a summary of: Corporate GHG emissions and financial performances: the moderating role of CEO overconfidence, International Journal of Managerial Finance, November 2026, Emerald,
DOI: 10.1108/ijmf-04-2026-0252.
You can read the full text:
Contributors
The following have contributed to this page







