What is it about?
This article presents a biographical reconstruction of the life of the painter Isaak Izrailevich Brodskii (1884–1939) through the lens of his painting Vladimir Lenin in Smolnyi (1930). Brodskii and his work are shown against the background of the terror of the 1930s, an ideological rupture in his artistic vision and his attainment of personal success. The diaries of Pavel N. Filonov (1883–1941) help us to see Brodskii from an unusual angle. Brodskii’s impulse to write articles was an impulse of “old art” (“Ars Nobilis”), collected in an exhibition that was held in the exhibition halls of Volkswagen in Berlin from October 18–27, 2002. Two portraits of Lenin by Brodksii were displayed there: Vladimir Lenin in Smolnyi and Lenin Reading Pravda (1930), from the private collection of Otto von Mitzlaff.
Featured Image
Why is it important?
In a broader context, the present reflections on Brodskii’s art have been inspired by the philosophical writings of Immanuel Kant, Edmund Husserl, and Martin Heidegger. Throughout the article, I assume that the truth of art may form part of the scientific truth. With the help of imagination or visualization, it is possible to unlock the “cognitive potential of works of art.” Imagination in this case is not “spontaneously irrational,” but a methodological instrument of cognition necessary for discovering “in full the meaning and complexity of works of art.” The reduction of an “artifact” and its life (including its perception by future generations) to a “bare painting” can narrow the context of interpretation to a minimum, turning the painting into a mere poster. Taking insights from art studies into consideration alongside the painter’s life allows us to enrich our understanding of a distant historical reality. As I see it, studying the work of art against the background of Brodskii’s life and those of his contemporaries helps us to better understand both the painting itself and the social, cultural, and psychological context of the time in which it was created. Fernando Luis González Rey notes the subtle interaction and interrelation of social and individual psychology: “In subjectivity, nothing new is configured as a result of a direct objective influence. . . . Subjectivity cannot be seen as a substance, but should be seen as a certain specific human production that is impossible to reduce to behavior, symbolic or cognitive processes, or any other given category.”10 For the interpretation of art, it is important to understand the role of subjectivity in the perception of reality. This “gap” between the selfproclaimed “documentary character” of Brodskii’s art and his subjective perception of reality is of particular interest to me.
Perspectives
The analysis of Brodskii’s work allows us to come to the conclusion that the “German” version is an independent piece of art related to the official versions of the painting. It could be considered as an experimental work in which the master was trying to find the appropriate technique for a truthful portrayal of his character. Brodskii was attempting to create a true-to-life picture of Lenin, and this aspiration led him to experiment with different methods and conceptual approaches. I will leave it to art experts to define what elements of Russian realism are reflected in this variant and to what extent it can be referred to as an example of socialist realism.
Dr. Andrei Keller
Ural Federal University
Read the Original
This page is a summary of: “Vladimir Lenin in Smolnyi” by Isaak I. Brodskii: The History of a Twin, Slavic Review, January 2017, Cambridge University Press,
DOI: 10.1017/slr.2017.82.
You can read the full text:
Resources
Contributors
The following have contributed to this page







