What is it about?

Are countries truly transitioning away from fossil fuels, or are they just adding renewable energy on top of existing fossil-fuel use? The study develops and applies an Energy Transition Index (ETI) to measure how successfully countries are moving from fossil fuels to cleaner energy sources. Unlike many indicators that only look at renewable energy growth, the ETI also considers whether renewable energy is actually replacing fossil fuels. What did the study do? Assessed energy-transition progress in 61 economies between 2000 and 2024. Compared countries' transition performance using the ETI. Examined how energy-transition progress relates to carbon emissions and economic development. What are the main findings? Expanding renewable energy alone does not guarantee a successful energy transition. Renewable energy must displace fossil-fuel consumption. Countries with stronger energy-transition performance tend to achieve greater reductions in CO₂ emissions. Government policies, technological progress, and investment are more important for transition success than economic growth by itself. Iceland was identified as the global leader, while New Zealand ranked third among the countries evaluated. Many countries claim success because renewable energy is growing rapidly. This paper shows that a more meaningful measure of progress is whether renewable energy is actually reducing dependence on coal, oil, and natural gas.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

This study is important because it challenges a common assumption in energy policy: More renewable energy does not necessarily mean a successful energy transition. A country may increase renewable energy generation while fossil-fuel consumption remains unchanged or even increases. The paper addresses several important gaps: Improves measurement of the energy transition. Many existing indicators focus on renewable-energy shares, but they may overstate progress if fossil fuels are not being displaced. The ETI explicitly considers both renewable-energy expansion and fossil-fuel substitution. Provides evidence-based benchmarking. By assessing 61 economies over 2000-2024, the study allows countries to compare their performance against global leaders such as Iceland and Norway. Links energy transition to climate outcomes. The findings show that stronger transition performance is associated with lower CO₂ emissions, highlighting the practical importance of genuine fossil-fuel displacement. Informs policy design. The results suggest that policy interventions, technological advancement, and investment are more influential than economic growth alone in achieving the energy transition. Enhances accountability. Governments often report renewable-energy growth as evidence of success. This framework provides a more rigorous assessment of whether decarbonisation is actually occurring.

Perspectives

1. Energy Economics Perspective The paper contributes to the long-standing debate on how energy transitions should be measured. Most studies focus on renewable-energy penetration, whereas this study argues that the key indicator is the extent to which renewables replace fossil fuels. 2. Climate Policy Perspective The findings support climate policies aimed at reducing fossil-fuel dependence rather than simply increasing renewable capacity. This distinction is crucial for achieving net-zero targets and meeting international climate commitments. 3. Sustainable Development Perspective The study demonstrates that energy transition and economic development are related but not synonymous. Higher income levels alone do not guarantee successful transition outcomes. Institutions, policies, and technological capabilities matter. 4. Measurement and Index Construction Perspective The ETI offers a methodological contribution by providing a more comprehensive metric for assessing transition progress. This can support future cross-country studies, policy evaluations, and international comparisons.

Dr Saeed Solaymani
saeedsolaymani@gmail.com

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: A Cross-Country Analysis of Energy Transition Progress, Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers - Energy, November 2026, Elsevier,
DOI: 10.1016/j.energy.2026.143126.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page