What is it about?

Plato’s programme for his ideal Republic involved establishing a "just" culture, in which its citizens would be committed to its success, by persuading them to believe a “noble lie”. Corporate leaders' programmes for maximising shareholder value often involve establishing "winning" cultures by persuading employees to believe selective stories of cultural compliance rewarded and cultural delinquency punished. Both programmes reflect "post-truth" thinking, whereby communicating the "right" moral messages matters more than telling verifiable truths. Plato justified manipulating people’s beliefs on the grounds that his philosopher-rulers were acting through unimpeachable wisdom and moral goodness. Corporate leaders justify manipulating employees’ beliefs on the grounds that they are acting through dutiful stewardship of the shareholder interest. This article considers the issues raised by Plato’s Republic as a guide to examining the ethical and practical issues raised by attempts to manage corporate culture.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

The management of corporate culture is typically considered from a managerialist perspective. By considering it from the point of view from the organisation members whose thoughts and feelings senior managers are to shape so as to align them with their desired corporate culture, this paper identifies some seldom considered and potentially problematic ethical issues.

Perspectives

Plato's Republic has attracted some harsh criticisms, notably by Karl Popper, as a totalitarian programme. Comparison between the writing of some advocates of managing corporate culture and some of the ideas in Plato's Republic sets the issues raised by this type of managerial initiative in sharp relief.

Dr David Shaw
Independent Researcher

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Plato’s “Noble Lie” and the Management of Corporate Culture, Philosophy of Management, February 2021, Springer Science + Business Media,
DOI: 10.1007/s40926-021-00168-y.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page