What is it about?

This case study explores the understandings seventh graders constructed with Gothic texts in a reading unit that I designed. The Gothic is a fictional genre defined by horror and mystery. The stories’ protagonists are often marginalized individuals. The genre was selected due to its popularity with adolescents. Qualitative data was collected and reviewed using thematic analysis. The results of the study reveal that as a result of grappling with the societal other, participants gleaned meaningful knowledge that enriched them personally and socially.

Featured Image

Why is it important?

The United States’ current climate is categorized by sharp divides and the marginalization of numerous groups, coupled with a general distrust and distaste of individual differences. Adolescents, now more than ever, need a space for discussing provocative and controversial texts (such as those of the Gothic genre) that gives voice to marginalized people. Additionally, the findings illustrate that texts and related conversations can help individuals develop empathy for others and increase tolerance and appreciation for individual differences. This highlights the need for curriculum with a vast array of texts including traditionally more neglected genres such as the Gothic, fantasy, and science fiction that can allow for such vicarious contrasting experiences.

Perspectives

This study came about my own evolved understanding regarding what 'counts' as 'meaningful' reading for adolescents. Prior to commencing my PhD studies, I was a middle school literacy instructor. Over time, I noticed that many of my students gravitated towards texts with Gothic themes. Yet, I found that the set curriculum I was working with did not contain these kinds of texts. I also wanted to understand why these texts resonated with adolescents. In being privy to their conversations surrounding their leisure reading, I began to see that the texts were not only enjoyable, but, that they were garnering understandings about themselves, each other, and the world. As a researcher, I wanted to understand how students would respond to a unit giving priority to these often marginalized texts.

Dr Jennifer R Del Nero
College of New Jersey

Read the Original

This page is a summary of: Embracing the Other in Gothic Texts: Cultivating Understanding in the Reading Classroom, Journal of Adolescent & Adult Literacy, September 2017, Wiley,
DOI: 10.1002/jaal.697.
You can read the full text:

Read

Contributors

The following have contributed to this page