What is it about?
The maintenance of CLT in Indonesia should consider but not limited four aspects: societal classroom, socio-economic, cultural, and ideological constraints. Indonesian EFL teachers have managed to adapt each of these methods to the situational contexts of their classrooms. The teachers’ flexibility in adapting the practices and theoretical approaches of different language teaching methods to Indonesian classrooms should be acknowledged and taken into account when considering the suitability of CLT, instead of an unquestioning acceptance of CLT as the only or the best method.
Featured Image
Why is it important?
Those four aspects impede the implementation of effective CLT instead of a narrow concept of CLT i.e., students sizes, structural curriculum, etc., as well as arguments against the idea of changing the status of English from EFL to ESL in Indonesia. However, it is necessary to carry out ”a deconstructive and reconstructive project". The former signifies the attempts to interrogate and critique established knowledge to suit the needs of the local, while the latter constitutes the interpretation of local knowledge to fit current conditions. An instance of such an attempt in the English classroom may be the reconstruction local wisdom or culture by using English. Teachers may ask their students to create and perform, in English, a drama derived from local cultures such as Indonesian folklore or the traditional puppet performance (Wayang). Such an activity gives students the opportunity to practice English communicative skills while expressing and maintaining their cultural heritage.
Perspectives
I hope that this article provides insight to the readers in regard to some constraints which impede the implementation of CLT in Indonesia. CLT holds a promise of a beneficial change in English teaching methodology from the old monotonous language teaching paradigm despite many constraints on its effective implementation. The approach itself and its underlying ideas are sound, but instead of adopting it wholesale it should be adapted to accommodate teachers’ and students’ needs and preferences in the context in which it is implemented. The mindless adoption of a single language teaching method or approach would lead to changes in the curricula, classroom practices, and teaching materials which may not be suitable for or viable in local contexts.
Eka Fadilah
Read the Original
This page is a summary of: Rethinking the Maintenance of CLT in Indonesia: A Response to Ariatna's “The Need for Maintaining CLT in Indonesia”, TESOL Journal, September 2017, Wiley,
DOI: 10.1002/tesj.341.
You can read the full text:
Contributors
The following have contributed to this page